WebClick Tracer

Skip to content
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Big Banks

P1.24B in limbo: COA flags DBP’s unverified MRT-3 investment valuation

By Bankero staff

The government’s rental payments for the use of MRT-3 were scheduled to end in January 2025. Nearly a year later, Development Bank of the Philippines (DBP) was still carrying a ₱1.24 billion investment tied to those payments without sufficient information to establish what it was actually worth.

The Commission on Audit (COA), in its 2025 audit report obtained by Bankero, questioned DBP’s valuation of preference shares in MRT III Funding Corporation Limited (M3FCL), a company incorporated in the Cayman Islands that issued securities backed by government rental payments for MRT-3.

The securities matured on February 7, 2025, just days after the government’s scheduled final monthly equity rental payment on January 31.

Yet as of December 31, DBP continued to value its investment at $21.08 million, equivalent to ₱1.24 billion, without updated information on the funds held at the Bank of New York, which served as trustee and paying agent.

COA said the investment’s fair value “was not determined based on its current market condition as of December 31, 2025,” contrary to Philippine Financial Reporting Standard 13.

The MRT-3 investment accounted for roughly 37.5% of DBP’s ₱3.30 billion portfolio of financial assets measured at fair value through profit or loss.

Because of the valuation deficiency, COA said the “faithful representation” of the reported ₱3.30 billion balance could not be established.

DBP’s investment dates back to 2009, when the Arroyo administration directed the state-owned lender and Land Bank of the Philippines to acquire financial interests in Metro Rail Transit Corporation (MRTC), the private company that developed MRT-3.

The two banks acquired roughly 80% of MRTC’s economic interests amid disputes between the government and the railway’s private investors.

The acquisition was intended to help the government gain control of MRTC’s board and address arbitration disputes over rental payments.

MRTC developed the 16.9-kilometer railway along EDSA under a build-lease-transfer agreement signed in 1997, which required the government to pay rental fees over 25 years.

Some of the private investors’ economic interests were packaged into bonds and preference shares issued by M3FCL, with government rental payments supporting the settlement of those securities.

When the preference shares matured in February 2025, DBP transferred its investment from financial assets measured at fair value through profit or loss to accounts receivable.

COA questioned the move, saying the accounting requirements for reclassifying the investment had not been satisfied.

DBP complied with the auditors’ recommendation and reversed the transfer, but still lacked the updated information needed to establish the investment’s current value.

The bank had valued its M3FCL preference shares at ₱1.214 billion at the end of 2024. The amount rose to ₱1.225 billion in February 2025 and ₱1.240 billion by December, partly reflecting movements in the peso-dollar exchange rate.

COA recommended that DBP continue asserting its rights as a preference shareholder to obtain the necessary records from the Bank of New York and make accounting adjustments if warranted.

In its response to auditors, DBP said it was coordinating with the Bank of New York, Maples Finance Limited, the administrator of the offshore arrangement, and M3FCL to obtain updated information on the remaining fund balance.

“These representations are being pursued to support the determination of the fair value of the Bank’s investment,” DBP management said.

The bank also committed to “assess and record any necessary adjustments to the related accounts upon receipt of reliable and sufficient information,” in accordance with accounting and regulatory requirements.

Latest News